AI Art Turing Test
Here are fifty pictures. Some of them (not necessarily exactly half) were made by humans; the rest are AI-generated. Please guess which are which. Please don't download them onto your computer, zoom in, or use tools besides the naked eye. Some hints:

- I've tried to balance type of picture / theme , so it won't be as easy as "everything that looks like digital art is AI".
- I've tried to crop some pictures of both types into unusual shapes, so it won't be as easy as "everything that's in DALL-E's default aspect ratio is AI".

At the end, it will ask you which picture you're most confident is human, which picture you're most confident is AI, and which picture was your favorite - so try to keep track of that throughout the exercise.

All the human pictures are by specific artists who deserve credit (and all the AI pictures are by specific prompters/AI art hobbyists who also deserve credit) but I obviously can't do that here. I'll include full attributions on the results post later.
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
NO LONGER ACCEPTING RESPONSES
Clear selection
Angel Woman
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Saint In Mountains
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Blue Hair Anime Girl
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Girl In Field
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Double Starship
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Bright Jumble Woman
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Cherub
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Praying In Garden
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Tropical Garden
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Ancient Gate
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Green Hills
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Bucolic Scene
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Anime Girl In Black
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Fancy Car
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Greek Temple
Captionless Image
Clear selection
String Doll
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Angry Crosses
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Rainbow Girl
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Creepy Skull
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Leafy Lane
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Ice Princess
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Celestial Display
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Mother And Child
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Fractured Lady
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Giant Ship
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Muscular Man
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Minaret Boat
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Purple Squares
Captionless Image
Clear selection
People Sitting
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Girl In White
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Riverside Cafe
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Serene River
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Turtle House
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Still Life
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Wounded Christ
Captionless Image
Clear selection
White Blob
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Weird Bird
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Ominous Ruin
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Vague Figures
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Dragon Lady
Captionless Image
Clear selection
White Flag
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Woman Unicorn
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Rooftops
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Paris Scene
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Final Six
I want to analyze the last six pictures on more depth. For these, please also give confidence levels (50% - 100% - if it's less than 50%, switch to the other answer!) and explain your answer.
Pretty Lake
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Pretty Lake Confidence
What percent confident are you in your answer?
Pretty Lake Explanation
Why did you choose the answer you did for this question?
Landing Craft
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Landing Craft Confidence
What percent confident are you in your answer?
Landing Craft Explanation
Why did you choose the answer you did for this question?
Flailing Limbs
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Flailing Limbs Confidence
What percent confident are you in your answer?
Flailing Limbs Explanation
Why did you choose the answer you did for this question?
Colorful Town
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Colorful Town Confidence
What percent confident are you in your answer?
Colorful Town Explanation
Why did you choose the answer you did for this question?
Mediterranean Town
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Mediterranean Town Confidence
What percent confident are you in your answer?
Mediterranean Town Explanation
Why did you choose the answer you did for this question?
Punk Robot
Captionless Image
Clear selection
Punk Robot Confidence
What percent confident are you in your answer?
Punk Robot Explanation
Why did you choose the answer you did for this question?
You're done with the pictures! Just a few more questions...
Which picture are you most confident was human?
Clear selection
Which picture are you most confident was AI?
Clear selection
Which picture is your favorite?
Clear selection
What is your level of familiarity with human art?
Clear selection
What is your level of familiarity with AI art?
Clear selection
How many of these pictures had you already seen before?
Clear selection
What percent of images do you think you got right?
Clear selection
Was this easier or harder than you expected?
Much easier
Much harder
Clear selection
Which of these strategies did you use most?
Clear selection
Any other strategies you used?
Any other opinions on this test?
What is your opinion of AI art on an artistic level?
IE not social/political concerns about it putting human artists out of work, but whether or not it is potentially good art with positive artistic value
More negative
More positive
Clear selection
If you're willing, can you explain your answer above?
Email (optional)
If you give me your email and do the best of anyone on the test, I'll email you and ask if you want to be publicly recognized
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Does this form look suspicious? Report