Aviation's CO2 Crisis: Debunking Airlines' Net-Zero Illusions

The aviation industry is masking its true colors when it comes to sustainability progress.

• Glossy marketing campaigns proudly proclaim so-called "Green Fares"—but there's nothing green about flying. 

• Airlines offer "CO2 Offsetting." However, many experts label such offsetting as largely fraudulent. 

• Then, there are the more trivial sustainability efforts that somehow make headlines, like the introduction of non-plastic cabin cutlery, as if such gestures have any bearing on a flight's CO2 emissions.

Beyond these superficial greenwashing tactics, airline CEOs and industry advocates frequently roll out fresh sustainability slogans and non-binding net-zero outlooks that are grounded in mere wishful thinking. 

All of this masks an unsettling reality: 

The aviation sector's sustainability trajectory is on the brink of disaster.

We think it's a “Mayday” call for the industry to face the hard truth about where aviation's CO2 impact is heading. 

Rather than progressing towards net-zero, the situation is deteriorating, and aviation is quickly moving towards becoming one of the top environmental offenders across the industry landscape. 

If you think we're overreacting, let's dive deep into a handful of key charts, citing mostly publicly available information. However, this data is often ignored or blatantly downplayed by most airline CEOs and industry figureheads.

The Inconvenient Truth of Aviation's Emissions

The initial chart paints a disturbing picture, revealing a fundamental shortcoming of the aviation industry: while other transport sectors have made strides in separating growth from emissions, aviation stands alone in its inability to do so.

Electric vehicles have provided the automotive world with a path to a greener future, decoupling their expansion from greenhouse gas emissions. However, aviation, grappling with the immense technological challenge of transporting hundreds of people in aircraft weighing an average of 100 tons – a task too energy-intensive for today's battery technology – hasn't found its green breakthrough.

While airline CEOs and industry proponents may boast improved CO2 per passenger mile statistics, these don't tell the whole story.

• Yes, individual flights might be becoming marginally more efficient, but the sheer volume of new flights and passengers projected in the coming decade will easily outpace these gains. 

• In plain terms, even as each flight emits a tad less, the sky will be saturated with more flights than ever before. This means that the industry's total carbon footprint is set to soar by nearly 50% by the end of the decade. 

And here's the kicker: this anticipated 50% increase in emissions by the end of the decade even factors into the International Energy Agency (IEA) ’s Announced Pledges Scenario (APS). This model already incorporates some of the lofty ambitions and targets proclaimed by major industry stakeholders. So, in essence, these figures represent an optimistic outlook. The reality could be much darker.

From "Just" 2-3% to a Quarter of Global Emissions

For years, aviation leaders have defended their industry's environmental impact with a single, seemingly modest statistic: aviation is responsible for only 2-3% of global emissions. The argument goes something like this: Why target an industry that contributes such a marginal slice of the environmental problem?

But the narrative is about to shift, and dramatically so.

According to our projections—using expected aviation emissions modeled by Boeing and total CO2 forecasts in the APS scenario from the IEA—with the steep increase in aviation's total CO2 emissions over the next decade, its contribution will double to 5% in less than a mere eight years. 

If we continue on this trajectory, by 2050, aviation alone will account for a staggering quarter of all CO2 emissions globally. This outlook is more or less confirmed by the Energy Transition Commission, which projects that aviation could be responsible for 22% of global emissions by 2050.

The repercussions of such an escalation are immense and largely unpredictable. 

One thing, however, is certain: the mounting pressure and public scrutiny will challenge the very essence of aviation. As a society, we'll be forced to question: Is the connectivity and convenience offered by aviation worth the looming environmental calamity?

Modern Fleet and Efficiency Gains Barely Scratch the Surface

When put on the spot about mitigating the colossal climate impact of aviation, aviation professionals often reach for the familiar comfort of two primary solutions: fleet renewals and operational efficiency enhancements. 

• They speak of replacing older aircraft with state-of-the-art models that boast a 25% reduction in CO2 emissions. 

• They champion the promise of intelligent flight routing, the potential of a Single European Sky, and a plethora of other strategies to conserve fuel.

But here's the harsh reality.

While we welcome any old gas guzzler being replaced by more efficient airplanes, such steps alone won’t make a significant dent.

In fact, even with the rosiest of forecasts, these initiatives only begin to scratch the surface. 

Boeing's own projections show that these measures combined—both the fleet renewals and efficiency enhancements—will barely soften the emissions increase, covering only about 25-30% of 2050's predicted emissions. This leaves a gigantic gap, where nearly 75% of the industry's future emissions stand unchecked and unaddressed as of today.

How can we address this gap?

Electric and hydrogen propulsion, while promising on paper, remain improbable solutions by 2050, especially for long-haul flights that dominate the emissions statistics. 

That leads us to the aviation sector's lifeline—Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF). Yet, even in this last bastion of hope, there's a facade. As we'll unravel in a second, the industry's smile masks a deeply concerning reality for SAF's prospects.

Aviation's (Non-Existing) SAF Lifeline

Sustainable Aviation Fuel has quickly become the talk of the town in aviation. From massive carriers to boutique airlines, everyone seems to be jumping on the SAF bandwagon. Airlines have showcased SAF-powered demonstration flights, announced elaborate purchasing agreements with fuel providers, launched SAF-centered compensation schemes for customers, and fostered numerous partnerships, all in the name of promoting SAF. 

The message being sent out is loud and clear: aviation has found its escape route from the impending climate disaster, and that route is paved with SAF.

But let's zoom out from these glossy announcements and look at the actual data.

The SAF utilization this year paints a rather bleak picture.

• A mere 0.45 Mt of SAF is expected to be used by the entire aviation industry.

• When put against the colossal 300 Mt jet fuel demand in 2023, this represents a paltry 0.15% of the total—indeed, it's akin to a single drop in a vast fuel tank.

The fundamental issue is twofold: there's a glaring shortage of SAF availability, and the efforts by the aviation (and energy) sector to ramp up SAF production are, at best, lethargic. 

Current projections reveal that even with all the new SAF plants in the pipeline, only around 8.4 million tonnes of SAF will be produced by 2030. 

The irony? 

Airlines have already locked in offtake agreements for SAF that significantly surpass this projected production. 

One example is United Airlines, which recently announced that it would purchase up to 1 billion gallons of sustainable aviation fuel from Houston-based Cemvita Inc.—over a time frame of 20 years!

In essence, the industry is, quite prematurely, counting on SAF supplies that won't even exist by the end of this decade.

As a detrimental consequence of the supply chain crunch, SAF fuel supply deals have slowed down this year, at a time when they should be growing exponentially.

So, what would it take for the aviation sector to significantly amplify its SAF uptake? 

A massive expansion of SAF production capacity is mission-critical.

According to estimates from MPP, the industry would need to green-light and commission up to 400 new SAF plants TODAY to achieve a supply level of 40-50 million tonnes by 2030. 

Even with such an ambitious expansion, SAF would still only cover around 15% of the projected total jet fuel demand in 2030. Such a target is often cited as a non-negotiable milestone for the aviation sector if it truly intends to play its part in adhering to the 1.5°C climate warming limit.

A Flight Plan to Real Sustainability

With all these stats in mind, it's not our intention to demonize the industry. At the Sustainable Aero Lab, we are part of the industry, too, and we deeply appreciate what aviation has brought to the world.

However, the aviation sector stands at a future-defining inflection point. Too many industry stakeholders pretend everything is alright when, in reality, it's far from it. The aviation industry has yet to discover how to decouple growth from emissions.

The only logical next step for aviation is action. Less talk about sustainability and more genuine commitments.

Here's what we propose:

1. Commit to Honest Accountability

The aviation industry needs to remove its green facade.

We must confront the sobering reality: given our current technological capabilities, achieving net-zero for the aviation sector is like a distant dream.

Let’s not mince words. With today’s effort, we're not even scratching the surface of net-zero ambitions. Today’s greenwashing propaganda around incremental improvements will not reverse the existing trend lines.

2. Capital for Genuine Change

The sustainability challenge facing aviation is not just an advocacy issue akin to a civil rights challenge; it's fundamentally a technological hurdle.

Real change demands radical innovation.

And what drives innovation? Capital. Investments in pioneering SAF facilities, ground-breaking research into electric propulsion, and other initiatives that aim to revolutionize our existing paradigms are paramount.

The urgency for capital infusion is immense. Credible estimates, like those from International Civil Aviation Organization, suggest that achieving net-zero for the aviation sector could cost a staggering $4-5 trillion USD by 2050. To contextualize this amount, it exceeds what the entire airline industry has spent on jet fuel over the past 30 years!

The scale of this crisis is unprecedented. 

One might argue it's the most significant challenge the sector has confronted since the Wright brothers pioneered flight.

The Role of the Sustainable Aero Lab

At the Sustainable Aero Lab, we are deeply committed to challenging the status quo, unveiling greenwashing tactics, and powering true innovation in aviation.

Our efforts aren’t just confined to reporting and research:

• To date, we have mentored over 60 startups keen on ushering in substantial change in the aviation sector.

• Our network includes over 40 dedicated mentors from the global aviation industry, all passionately striving to see this change materialize.

Yet, despite three years of ongoing discussions and outreach, we still find the wider aviation industry, from manufacturers to airlines, largely absent in their support. While individual professionals within the sector recognize the challenges and express a desire to be part of the solution, the overarching industry seems slow to respond.

It's precisely this gap between industry rhetoric and action that drives us to champion transparency. 

We believe that by shedding light on the actual progress, or lack thereof, we can cultivate a sense of urgency and propel the industry toward genuine, tangible change.

Transparency is at the heart of change. Through monthly, data-driven articles like this one, we intend to counteract misleading greenwashing claims by airlines.

But our objective isn't simply to point out shortcomings. Primarily, our research aims to highlight genuine airline sustainability leaders, promoting a culture that values both accountability and action.

True commitment is reflected through actions, particularly those involving monetary investments in innovation and technology.

• With this inaugural article of our "Net-Zero Transparency" series, we plan to spotlight the real strides airlines are making towards net-zero.

• We will use a pragmatic approach of introducing and analyzing specific and easy-to-understand metrics that reflect tangible financial commitments for a sustainable aviation future.

• In essence, we want net-zero investments to be measured and reported with the same rigor and transparency as corporate R&D budgets, indicating a true focus on sustainability and disruptive innovation. 

By doing so, we aim to foster a culture of accountability and encourage more airlines to commit to real financial investments, ultimately driving the entire industry towards a sustainable future.

Stay updated with our monthly newsletter to discover more.